Exaggerated responses to spring performances by every team listed in the premature Top 25 rankings.
Spring marks the height of overreactions in college football. Emerging freshmen, backup quarterbacks suddenly in the Heisman spotlight, and transfers viewed as potential game-changers in championship pursuits dominate the conversation.
As spring practices conclude and anticipation for the upcoming season intensifies, our reporters examine exaggerated responses for each team in the latest Top 25 preseason rankings.
1. Georgia
Overreaction: Georgia’s offensive prowess will diminish significantly without star players Brock Bowers and Ladd McConkey.
While the Bulldogs will undoubtedly feel the absence of these standout receivers, there’s optimism for the returning talent and incoming recruits. Quarterback Carson Beck, poised for a strong second season, leads the charge, supported by promising receivers Dominic Lovett and Rara Thomas. Transfers like Dillon Bell and Colbie Young add depth to the receiving corps, while tight end Oscar Delp and transfer Benjamin Yurosek provide additional targets.
2. Ohio State
Overreaction: Freshman standout Jeremiah Smith will seamlessly replace Marvin Harrison Jr. as Ohio State’s primary wide receiver.
Smith’s impressive spring performance has generated excitement, but senior Emeka Egbuka’s consistency and leadership solidify his role as the go-to receiver. With a new quarterback and offensive play-caller, Egbuka’s experience and reliability offer stability to Ohio State’s offense.
3. Oregon
Overreaction: Oregon will adopt a physical style suited for the Big Ten conference.
While skepticism surrounds the transition of former Pac-12 teams to the Big Ten, Oregon’s spring game showcased their commitment to physicality. Coach Dan Lanning emphasized effort and aggression, indicating readiness for the challenges ahead. Oregon’s athleticism and intensity suggest they’ll compete effectively in the new conference environment.
4. Texas
Overreaction: A quarterback controversy looms for Texas.
Despite Arch Manning’s impressive spring showing, Quinn Ewers remains the clear starter. Coach Sarkisian’s faith in Ewers, proven by past decisions, reaffirms his position as the Longhorns’ leader. Manning’s opportunity to develop further during spring reflects long-term planning rather than immediate competition.
5. Notre Dame
Overreaction: Quarterback Riley Leonard’s injury history raises concerns.
Although Leonard’s injury sidelined him for spring practices, his experience and resilience position him as Notre Dame’s offensive linchpin. While his absence may raise initial worries, Leonard’s veteran status and spring recovery offer reassurance for the upcoming season.
6. Ole Miss
Overreaction: Complacency won’t affect Ole Miss.
Despite Coach Kiffin’s dismissal of “rat poison,” heightened expectations pose a new challenge for Ole Miss. With a talented roster and a seasoned quarterback in Jaxson Dart, managing external pressures becomes crucial. The team must navigate the playoff expectations while maintaining focus and humility.
7. Missouri
Overreaction: Offensive line changes will hinder Missouri’s offense.
While losing key linemen presents a challenge, Missouri’s additions through transfers bolster their offensive line. With improved depth and talent, the Tigers are well-equipped to support quarterback Brady Cook and sustain offensive productivity. Injury prevention will be key to realizing their offensive potential.
