Heart of Ohio Is Taken? Former Michigan Coach Jim Harbaugh Accuses Ohio State of Stealing Star Recruit Jeremiah Smith
In a controversy that has sent shockwaves through the college football community, former Michigan Wolverines head coach Jim Harbaugh has publicly accused the Ohio State Buckeyes of unethical recruitment practices, specifically targeting their successful acquisition of five-star wide receiver Jeremiah Smith.
Jeremiah Smith, widely regarded as one of the most talented prospects in the 2024 class, had long been linked with multiple powerhouse programs. However, his final decision to commit to Ohio State over other suitors—most notably Michigan—has now become a point of contention after Harbaugh’s recent comments raised eyebrows and reignited the fierce rivalry between the two Big Ten giants.
Harbaugh Speaks Out
Speaking at a private alumni event in Los Angeles that was later reported by multiple sources, Harbaugh reportedly stated, “We had our sights set on Jeremiah. He was ours to lose, and frankly, we believe he was taken—not chosen. Certain promises were made that go beyond the bounds of fair competition.”
Though Harbaugh stopped short of directly accusing Ohio State of breaking NCAA regulations, his cryptic phrasing has been interpreted by many as an allegation of tampering or improper benefits—accusations that, if substantiated, could have significant implications for both programs.
“Recruiting has become the wild west,” Harbaugh added. “NIL deals, promises, influence—some schools are willing to cross lines that we wouldn’t.”
Jeremiah Smith: The Center of Attention
Smith, a 6’3” wideout from Chaminade-Madonna Prep in Florida, has been on the radar of nearly every top football program in the country. Known for his elite speed, precise route-running, and strong hands, Smith is viewed by scouts as a future first-round NFL draft pick and a potential game-changer for any team he joins.
In response to the controversy, Smith released a brief statement via his social media account:
“I chose Ohio State because it felt like home and gave me the best path to develop as a player and a person. No one stole me. I made my choice.”
Despite the statement, speculation has continued to swirl regarding what went on behind the scenes of Smith’s recruitment process.
Ohio State Responds
The Buckeyes’ head coach Ryan Day was quick to respond to Harbaugh’s remarks in a press conference following spring practice.
“We recruit the right way,” Day said. “Always have, always will. If other programs are upset that elite players choose Ohio State, that speaks more to our culture and success than anything else. We’re proud Jeremiah chose to be a Buckeye.”
Day declined to comment further when pressed about potential NIL involvement or specific inducements offered during Smith’s recruitment.
A Rivalry Rekindled
The Harbaugh-Day rivalry has been a central storyline in the Michigan–Ohio State saga for nearly a decade. Even after Harbaugh’s departure to the NFL, the tension remains high. This latest controversy adds another chapter to a rivalry that has become as personal and dramatic as it is competitive.
Analysts believe Harbaugh’s comments may reflect broader frustrations among college coaches navigating the new era of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals and the NCAA transfer portal, where traditional recruiting practices are increasingly blurred by financial incentives and external influence.
What’s Next?
While no formal investigation has been launched as of now, insiders suggest that NCAA compliance offices are keeping a close watch on high-profile recruiting cases like Smith’s. The growing concern among coaches over NIL abuses may push governing bodies to revisit the boundaries and enforcement of recruiting regulations.
In the meantime, the Buckeyes march forward with another blue-chip talent in their arsenal, while Michigan faces life after Harbaugh—now not only without their head coach but potentially losing their grip on top national recruits.
Whether Harbaugh’s claims will be proven or dismissed, one thing remains clear: the battle between Michigan and Ohio State continues, both on and off the field. And with the heart of Ohio now beating in scarlet and gray, the Wolverines are left wondering what could have been.